Green Deal is a 'total failure', says Labour parliamentary candidate

Worcester News: The Green Deal: under attack by Councillor Joy Squires The Green Deal: under attack by Councillor Joy Squires

WORCESTER’S Labour parliamentary candidate has slammed the government’s Green Deal project – calling it an “epic failure”.

Councillor Joy Squires says households across Worcester have missed out since the plug was pulled on a multimillion pound deal to cut energy bills.

As your Worcester News revealed in December, Carillion decided to scrap a seven year deal with Worcester City Council to offer homes better insulation.

The company said the Green Deal, which is part-funded by the government, was proving too complicated and was not working elsewhere in the country.

Last year, energy minister Greg Barker said he would have “sleepness nights” if fewer than 10,000 people around the UK signed up to the Green Deal, but by December, just 700 had.

Coun Squires said: “As well as failing the many small companies that manufacture and install insulation and other energy efficiency measures, the Green Deal has been a total failure for consumers.

“It is bureaucratic, difficult to understand and clearly not trusted as a scheme by the public.”

The project would have led to the construction giant sending assessors into homes to improve their energy efficiency through things like better insulation or replacement boilers.

Residents can take out a long term loan, recouped as money comes off their utility bills.

Worcester MP Robin Walker said: “It’s fair criticism to say the scheme didn’t work as expected, but it hasn’t quite failed in the way Joy and Labour are implying.

“Although very large numbers have been assessed, a lot of people are paying to go ahead with the work without taking out a finance deal."

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:06pm Sat 18 Jan 14

PrivateSi says...

Would have been a lot fairer and simpler to remove VAT on insulation... Further subsidise by product 'greeness' to varying extents? NO, Just subsidise equally, if anything. I'm not into subsidising / financially punishing individual sub industries as it distorts the whole industry...

Air & ground pollution standards may distort markets but that's not the same as subsidising or punishing individual industries ON PURPOSE...

Solar Panels, for instance, were given a TAX PAYER FUNDED BOOST... Why is government obsessed with complicated paper trailed red taped bureaucracy over SIMPLE SYSTEMS...
Would have been a lot fairer and simpler to remove VAT on insulation... Further subsidise by product 'greeness' to varying extents? NO, Just subsidise equally, if anything. I'm not into subsidising / financially punishing individual sub industries as it distorts the whole industry... Air & ground pollution standards may distort markets but that's not the same as subsidising or punishing individual industries ON PURPOSE... Solar Panels, for instance, were given a TAX PAYER FUNDED BOOST... Why is government obsessed with complicated paper trailed red taped bureaucracy over SIMPLE SYSTEMS... PrivateSi
  • Score: 1

12:51pm Mon 20 Jan 14

Guy66 says...

Just one example of the green deal - new boiler - you need a green deal property assessment costing £129 to enable a claim from the pots of 'improvement cash'; for a boiler its up to £270 in cash. So you go ahead and spend £2K (£2000!!!) for a new boiler. Then you need to get a green deal reassessment costing £129 to see if you are correctly entitled to the £270. Anyone see an issue here? Loads of time and effort for £12.

Oh course if you are not working, claiming certain benefits, you are entitled to a free boiler. Clearly less and less incentive to make a honest living in this country!
Just one example of the green deal - new boiler - you need a green deal property assessment costing £129 to enable a claim from the pots of 'improvement cash'; for a boiler its up to £270 in cash. So you go ahead and spend £2K (£2000!!!) for a new boiler. Then you need to get a green deal reassessment costing £129 to see if you are correctly entitled to the £270. Anyone see an issue here? Loads of time and effort for £12. Oh course if you are not working, claiming certain benefits, you are entitled to a free boiler. Clearly less and less incentive to make a honest living in this country! Guy66
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree