Report this comment
  • "The facts are; We do not need to incinerate or landfill; there are better cheaper options used by other councils. Waste levels are falling and there is increasing incinerator capacity in the West Mids. The incinerator could cost over £1 billion of taxpayers money with or without PFI, disgraceful when £100 million is being slashed from council budgets. Large quantities of recyclable waste is being landfilled why? 25% of what is burned is ash, much of which goes to landfill???

    Councillor Smith, clearly a nimby himself, is badly informed like the rest of his contemporaries on WCC.
    His nimby colleagues seem to have wasted 10 years trying to find a site no where near them, to burn waste, instead of looking at better options. They have also employed consultants to help pass this project at even further expense to tax payers.

    Mr Smith does not realise that the nimby argument has long since moved on and the real issue is cost cost and even more cost.
    Has Mr Smith heard of PFI?
    Councils who have put the work in, now get much better deals for their tax payers, so Mr Smith taxpayers just need to replace the likes of you for someone who is better informed, no need to wait 50 years. Next May will be fine.

    Some councils have recycling levels of over 60% and are paid for their recyclable material. At £26 per tonne this doesn’t sound much but for 200,000 tonnes a year that is a benefit of over £5 million pounds.
    Currently this costs us over £5 million, so perhaps we are £10 million down to start with. The contractor then keeps all profit from selling the recyclable material.
    There are currently no plans to connect to the national grid and a potential £100 million will be lost in revenue as the rural location means there is not potential to use the heat.
    There is no final business case and the contract is a secret.
    They seem to have a better understanding of the issues in Hereford. See http://www.herefordt
    imes.com/news/local/
    10129331.__120m_stil
    l_needed_to_build_wa
    ste_incinerator/?ref
    =eb"
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Please be fair, courteous and respectful to the views of others so we can build a vibrant community in a safe online environment. You are personal liable for your comments and action will be taken against anyone who offends, ridicules or posts malicious and damaging views. If you wish to complain, please contact us.

Councillor: I understand anger over waste plant

ARTIST’S IMPRESSION: Campaigners have been bitterly fighting the plan for a £120 million incinerator in Hartlebury. ARTIST’S IMPRESSION: Campaigners have been bitterly fighting the plan for a £120 million incinerator in Hartlebury.

A LEADING Worcestershire politician has admitted he can understand campaigners’ anger over proposals for a £120 million incinerator in Hartlebury.

Councillor John Smith said he “would not want it” in his own back yard but has insisted the plan is the best way of disposing of rubbish.

Coun Smith is a former cabinet member for the environment at Worcestershire County Council, and was one of the politicians responsible for exploring alternatives 10 years ago.

Campaigners from the Herefordshire and Worcestershire Action Group have been bitterly fighting the plan, but despite the opposition £1.8 million is being spent on clearing the site for the scheme.

Coun Smith said: “I can understand the locals who don’t want it, if it was in your back yard or mine I wouldn’t want it either.

“But as a council we have taken independent advice on this and the answer is that this path is the right one to take.

“Many years ago when I was looking at all the options a new method was being developed whereby the waste could have been used as a substitute for concrete and other materials, but time has moved on now and this system is the best one we’ve got available.

“There may well be something even better in 50 years time, but we can’t afford to wait that long, we must find a solution now.

“We can’t do nothing – the amount of rubbish we are generating is increasing, more new homes are being built.

“Where will we dump all the rubbish? It can’t all go to landfill.”

The incinerator will power electricity to 20,000 homes by burning rubbish and is being launched under the management of West Mercia Waste.

Two weeks ago the county council’s cabinet agreed to investigate alternative funding for the facility amid concerns bank loans may not provide the best value for money.

In the meantime £1.8m has been put towards cleaning up the land.

Critics believe the total bill to taxpayers during the lifetime of the 25-year contract could reach £1 billion, but this has been rejected.

It will handle waste from Worcestershire and Herefordshire, where disposal costs total £39 million a year at the moment, and is likely to import rubbish from other counties.

Landfill taxes stand at £64 per tonne now, but will rise by £8 every year up to 2020, resulting in major pressure from the Government to find new solutions.

The new incinerators are also known as ‘energy from waste’ plants.

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree