- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Facebook
Worcester News
Like us on Facebook
Worcester News Sport
Like us on Facebook
Drink-drive PC caught using phone on motorway (From Worcester News)
Get involved! Send your photos, video, news & views by texting WN NEWS to 80360 or e-mail us
Drink-drive PC caught using phone on motorway
7:30am Wednesday 9th January 2013 in News
By James Connell
A POLICE officer was caught drink-driving as she used her mobile phone on the M5 near Worcester.
PC Amy Stuart has been told that she faces losing her job as a police officer after she was stopped between junctions 7 and 8 of the M5.
The 33-year-old admitted driving with excess alcohol and using a handheld mobile phone on December 23 when she appeared before magistrates in Worcester yesterday.
The court was told how officers were on patrol in the outside lane of the M5 heading northbound when they overtook Stuart’s black BMW and saw she was holding a mobile phone in her right hand to her right ear.
Matt Dodson, prosecuting, said: “She stated she had been speaking with her partner. Officers confirmed they could smell alcohol on her breath and required a roadside breath test from her.”
An alcohol reading of 57mcg was recorded at the roadside and a reading of 53mcg at Worcester police station, the figure used as evidence (the legal limit is 35mcg).
Mr Dodson said Stuart, of Victoria Circus, Tewkesbury, had no previous convictions, reprimands or cautions and held a full, clean driving licence at the time.
Nick Smith, defending, said references described her as compassionate and with a great sense of duty and said she was a serving police officer and a police liaison officer in Birmingham.
He said: “She has been an officer since 2004 with an exemplary record. It has been a difficult year. She split from her partner of four years in June and he took his son with him.”
Mr Smith also said she had problems evicting a tenant from a flat she owned where she now lives.
Mr Smith said she had been out the night before with friends in Tewkesbury and “didn’t realise how much she had drunk”. He said police officers had not pulled her over for erratic driving but because she was using her phone.
He said: “It is usual that police officers lose their jobs when they’re caught drink- driving. I don’t say it’s absolutely inevitable but there’s a very, very high risk of it.
“She is a dedicated officer and wishes to continue in that. She fully accepts what she did was wrong and she knows, as an officer, one should be careful.
“She overlooked the circumstances the night before – she was stupid and silly and she is ashamed of her actions. She realises she has brought herself into disrepute and, by way of her behaviour, the force into disrepute.”
Magistrates banned her from driving for 12 months and fined her £400 for drink- driving. She was fined £130 for the mobile phone offence and her licence will be endorsed with three penalty points. She was also ordered to pay £85 costs and a victim surcharge of £40.
If she completes a drink-drive course she can be back on the road by October 9.
After the hearing a spokesman for West Midlands Police said: “We can confirm she is a serving West Midlands Police officer and an internal misconduct investigation will now commence.”
Comments(18)
reflector
says...
9:00am Wed 9 Jan 13
She must have known how much she had to drink the night before and using her mobile phone was a quite deliberate act which she knew full well was both illegal and dangerous.
I've no sympathy at all I am afraid and agree that she ought to resign.
More Tea Vicar
says...
2:18pm Wed 9 Jan 13
I know there are plenty of decent people in the police force, and that even at its worst, our police compares pretty well with normal in many countries.
But this seems to be yet another incident indicating an organisation with severe attitude issues.
littlejohn2
says...
4:50pm Wed 9 Jan 13
.
pronstar
says...
6:24pm Wed 9 Jan 13
littlejohn2 wrote:I take it then that you know this particular plod to take time out from your busy, exciting life to come on here defending her and lecturing others.
All you do gooders tickle me , yes she did do wrong .And no doubt deeply regret's what she did , and should have known better .. But at the end of the day police officers are human just like the rest of us . ( well most of them ) .And before one of you try jumping all over me I've never drunk any type of alcohol in my life and I'm banging the door of 60 .But like 99% of you I can not claim to have been a mr perfect .I hope she keeps her job , not lose it like some are crying out for .I'm sure this can only make her a better officer in the future There seems to be a lot of sad lonely people visit this site who;s only pleasure is shooting down other people . Get a life .
.
I don't see how getting caught is going to make her a better officer in the future. If she needs to be able to drive to do her job, and I assume that she does, she can't really do it if she's banned from driving can she?
Banging on the door of 60 or not, you really should know how to use punctuation properly.
littlejohn2
says...
7:11pm Wed 9 Jan 13
pronstar wrote:Your answer , No ! I have no idea who she is . And your a fine example of my comment .Just have to pick on other folk or find fault.
littlejohn2 wrote:I take it then that you know this particular plod to take time out from your busy, exciting life to come on here defending her and lecturing others.
All you do gooders tickle me , yes she did do wrong .And no doubt deeply regret's what she did , and should have known better .. But at the end of the day police officers are human just like the rest of us . ( well most of them ) .And before one of you try jumping all over me I've never drunk any type of alcohol in my life and I'm banging the door of 60 .But like 99% of you I can not claim to have been a mr perfect .I hope she keeps her job , not lose it like some are crying out for .I'm sure this can only make her a better officer in the future There seems to be a lot of sad lonely people visit this site who;s only pleasure is shooting down other people . Get a life .
.
I don't see how getting caught is going to make her a better officer in the future. If she needs to be able to drive to do her job, and I assume that she does, she can't really do it if she's banned from driving can she?
Banging on the door of 60 or not, you really should know how to use punctuation properly.
sad person
iamthebinman
says...
10:33pm Wed 9 Jan 13
littlejohn2 wrote:I agree. Stop judging people as I doubt you are perfect and don't comment on punctuation as it's very very sad. Let the lassie keep her job if for nothing else to annoy those who feel they have the right to pick on her!
pronstar wrote:Your answer , No ! I have no idea who she is . And your a fine example of my comment .Just have to pick on other folk or find fault.
littlejohn2 wrote:I take it then that you know this particular plod to take time out from your busy, exciting life to come on here defending her and lecturing others.
All you do gooders tickle me , yes she did do wrong .And no doubt deeply regret's what she did , and should have known better .. But at the end of the day police officers are human just like the rest of us . ( well most of them ) .And before one of you try jumping all over me I've never drunk any type of alcohol in my life and I'm banging the door of 60 .But like 99% of you I can not claim to have been a mr perfect .I hope she keeps her job , not lose it like some are crying out for .I'm sure this can only make her a better officer in the future There seems to be a lot of sad lonely people visit this site who;s only pleasure is shooting down other people . Get a life .
.
I don't see how getting caught is going to make her a better officer in the future. If she needs to be able to drive to do her job, and I assume that she does, she can't really do it if she's banned from driving can she?
Banging on the door of 60 or not, you really should know how to use punctuation properly.
sad person
Jabbadad
says...
12:11am Thu 10 Jan 13
jb
says...
9:33am Thu 10 Jan 13
Firstly, she's got a criminal conviction although there are serving officers with convictions according to some reports. Secondly what is her service record like? Has it been exemplary, if so was this completely out of character for her.
Finally, she put colleagues although from another force they are still colleagues, in the unenviable position of prosecuting a fellow officer. They did their job.
I would look at it from the perspective that (playing devils advocate)so much in time and money has been invested in her training and service, she has been punished by the court and more than likely lost any chance of promotion. BUT she committed an offence, well two offences that could have and have had in many incidents caused death or injury on the roads. That, to me would be the main consideration when any decision on her future.
Jim F
says...
11:14am Thu 10 Jan 13
Respectable
says...
1:57pm Thu 10 Jan 13
Jabbadad
says...
3:42pm Thu 10 Jan 13
spider666
says...
5:21pm Thu 10 Jan 13
Jabbadad wrote:And what if the police had overlooked this and let her drive on and then she crashed and killed or seriously hurt either herself or someone else
If the police closed ranks as stated, and looked after one of their own (I happen to believe that they should) then she wouldn't have been reported by another police officer would she. I understand that Traffic police and others are extremely competitive. Some may say good, I say look after your colleagues your life may depend on them and by all means punish them but within the force, not publicly.
reflector
says...
6:59pm Thu 10 Jan 13
Jabbadad
says...
7:31pm Thu 10 Jan 13
Vox populi
says...
1:08am Sat 12 Jan 13
Worcesterwench
says...
2:26am Sat 12 Jan 13
Catkins1
says...
9:20pm Sat 12 Jan 13
She has got what she deserved very pleased especially after she gave me a lecture for using a mobile phone whilst driving which I was not. So being caught using a mobile phone and plus the fact she was way over the drink driving limit the following day after a night out with friends is not exactly a good example of how a police officer should behave.
Respectable says...
8:23am Wed 9 Jan 13
Fortunately, it looks like the courts have applied the law, to the letter, as they would do for Joe Public.
I wonder how many times this WELL experienced officer has lectured members of the public (may who would be paying her wages) on the what is right and wrong ? She should do the decent and honourable thing and offer her resignation.. It would the be up to Police management to decide whether they accept it or not. How can she expect to ever have any credibility after MULIPLE offences during what would have been the ANNUAL drink drive campaign.