Soaring cost of burning rubbish

CAMPAIGNERS fighting plans for an incinerator for the two counties claim the set-up costs could rocket by another £46 million.

Independent assessors have published information revealing the plant in Hartlebury could cost at least £166 million to get off the ground. The figure has been rejected by Worcestershire County Council, which says it is confident a £120 million estimate will prove accurate.

Entec UK, an environmental consultancy, was given the task of drafting details on the likely cost for building the huge facility.

Documents supplied to County Hall, unearthed after a request under the Freedom of Information Act, state: “The capital cost for a facility of this size is estimated to be in the order of £166 million.”

It also goes on to say how the estimate could rise another 30 to 50 per cent on top of that.

The details also came with a separate guide on a number of “risks” surrounding the project, which included councils meeting recycling targets, thereby not producing enough waste, and costs rising during the lifetime of the plant.

The consultant’s report was sent to council chiefs back in 2009.

A spokesman for Herefordshire and Worcestershire Action Group said: “People need to face up to the huge risks associated with this.

“We have not seen a business plan and are very concerned about the costs and the problems that go with it – we need to know how much of our taxes are going into this.”

The county council has yet to publish a detailed business case for the scheme but is continuing to back the £120 million figure.

Councillor Anthony Blagg, the cabinet member for environment, said: “The figure referred to in the independent report dates back to 2009 – since then, as more details have been confirmed, the capital costs have been refined, leading to the current expected capital cost for the facility of £120 million. As with any major project of this kind there is always a managed risk.

“However, sitting back and doing nothing when it comes to reducing how much waste goes to landfill is not an option.”

The council would not say why the estimated costs have dropped.

Planning permission for the EnviRecover plant was granted by the Government last July.

Comments(3)

laidback says...
8:13am Mon 14 Jan 13

The Entec UK CAPEX figure is within the correct envelope. Similar 200,000t/a ~15MWe WtE plant design and construction/erectio
n projects that I have technically reviewed over the past two years for the London Engineering Insurance Market have been well in excess of GBP 150M build and commissioning contract value.

say no to garden grabbing says...
7:04pm Tue 15 Jan 13

Are we in danger here of allowing the Council to hide the facts? Looking at the Capital costs alone is about as ill thought out as buying a car with the lowest screen price whilst having full knowledge that its the most expensive to run and maintain!

The TOTAL COST of this incinerator is going to cost the taxpayer over £1BILLION!! based on comparative figures (the council have repeatedly been asked for whole life budget costs for all options so that it can be demonstrated that they are making decisions in the public interest.... they REFUSE to provide this information). This is not 'commercially sensitive’ as it is budget whole life costs that have been requested. Is it the case that they do not have this information, which would be extremely worrying, or that they are knowingly ignoring cheaper alternatives. Now let’s factor in them making cuts to so many needed services in other areas and any intelligent person can see that costs of this magnitude should be open and transparent.

Makes you wonder why Scrutiny are not interested? Perhaps May will bring us councillors who are prepared to make open and honest decisions.

Mrfade says...
11:46pm Tue 15 Jan 13

May, may be too late. This is our money. Protest to your MP, County Councillor, district councillor, tell everyone.

Deep fiancial scrutiny is needed urgently.or we have 25 years of additional debt to endure...

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree