Anglers say they might have to shoot our Keith

MEAL TIME: Keith the seal with a duck she captured at Bewdley. Picture by Gary Mayner. MEAL TIME: Keith the seal with a duck she captured at Bewdley. Picture by Gary Mayner.

THE tide appears to be turning for celebrity seal Keith with anglers calling for the wayward animal to be shot as a drastic last resort if it cannot be removed from the river Severn any other way.

The Angling Trust has written to a number of organisations, including the Environment Agency, demanding the seal, who has been spotted in Worcester, Upton-upon-Severn and Bewdley, be relocated to protect fish stocks.

If nothing can be done to remove or deter the seal, the trust claims it will be forced to secure a licence to shoot it using a qualified marksman.

In a statement on the trust’s website, chief executive Mark Lloyd said: “We think that the Environment Agency or Natural England should have taken action before now to protect vulnerable fish stocks in the river Severn.

“This marine predator cannot be allowed to carry on eating its way through freshwater fish that have taken decades to grow to a size.

“We will try everything possible to remove it humanely but more drastic action may be the only option if these methods do not work.”

The trust claims it has contacted the Environment Agency, which declined its request; the British Divers Marine Life Rescue organisation, which said it would be too difficult to capture the animal safely; and the company Aquatec, which provides seal scarers that emit a high-pitched noise.

The Environment Agency and RSPCA said they would not take action as the seal would naturally make its way back to the sea.

An EA spokesman said: “We understand the concerns of salmon and coarse fisheries and anglers.

“One animal in a large river like the Severn is unlikely to have a significant impact on fish stocks.

“This is ‘natural predation’ and it will eventually make its own way back out to sea.

“With this is mind, and also because seals are a protected species, we won’t be taking action.”

A RSPCA spokesman said: “It's not uncommon for seals to venture away from the sea. As long as the seal is not injured or in any immediate danger then we would not be concerned for its welfare.”

Stuart Anderson, of Bewdley, a member of the Pike Anglers Club of Great Britain, said: “I am very worried as it now has started taking ducks and waterfowl and soon will start attacking swans and maybe dogs swimming.”

Bewdley resident Gary Mayner took a photo of Keith with a duck in its mouth.

He said: “Like everybody else at first I thought that it was nice to see a seal. But the more I thought about it, having just witnessed it killing then eating a duck, it’s not quite right having it here.”

Comments(13)

pronstar says...
10:38am Fri 18 Jan 13

Time to disappear Keith

Jabbadad says...
11:08am Fri 18 Jan 13

It's really astonishing how dare these Anglers ( a lot of silly people who wish to sit in all weathers and dangle their bait and bits in the water ) to take on a little fish (in comparison to mankind) and yank it out of the water into a keep net then let it go, have the audacity to threaten another Mammal simply because what he is doing is a natural thing by feeding. I think that these brave people should look at the food chain and explain why their precious fish should be allowed to devour the food that keeps them alive??? Nature should be allowed to take it's course and Keith (Bless) should be allowed after a snack or two, to move on when ready.

susanna24 says...
11:17am Fri 18 Jan 13

I agree with jabbadad,
leave the poor seal alone he is beautiful to see and will go on when he is ready.
I think that there will be a public outcry if it is shot.

imustbeoldiwearacap says...
11:17am Fri 18 Jan 13

So what next, shoot every heron and other fish predator on the Severn! It's only ONE seal - I think the anglers have spent too much time on their own with only the fish in their keep-nets to talk to!

susanna24 says...
11:18am Fri 18 Jan 13

I agree with jabbadad,
leave the poor seal alone he is beautiful to see and will go on when he is ready.
I think that there will be a public outcry if it is shot.

Hack says...
11:25am Fri 18 Jan 13

As a keen angler, fresh and salt water, this proposal, if carried out will backfire on anglers. There is also the legality. The Trust has no jurisdiction over the Severn, so any rogue marksman would need a kill shot, or I would expect RSPCA to take action on cruelty. Possibily police interest for discharging a weapon from a public footpath.
Pike and Zander, also larger Perch are carnivores. Pike take young ducklings, but do we suggest culling all pike? Pike also take other fish. We also catch and eat Pike, Zander and Perch (not personally but have eaten Pike).
The EA is correct. The seal will have no significant impact on fish or wildlife stocks.

pudniw_gib says...
12:51pm Fri 18 Jan 13

Well said Hack...

Dharma says...
1:13pm Fri 18 Jan 13

I agree with earlier comments. Anglers regard pulling fish from the water with barbed hooks in their mouths as sport; many might disagree. Keith is taking what she (it is thought it is a female) needs to live. How much can she eat? Leave her alone and let us enjoy seeing this beautiful creature.

®og says...
2:01pm Fri 18 Jan 13

The course of the River Severn has been as it now is for tens of thousands of years - with minor deviations caused by natural flooding. Before the locks and weirs there were almost certainly more seals venturing up the River to Bewdley and beyond. I'm not sure how many times it has to be said before these fishermen get the message - the fish and seals were there long before you and will be there long after you, the fish are food for the seals and not provided for your, so called, sport - get over it - if there are no fish for a few years due to seal activity then take up knitting.

OrdinaryMan says...
3:00pm Fri 18 Jan 13

I was fairly ambivilent about the seal (after all, its just an aquatic creature doing what it does - swimming in water and eating what it needs).

I now hope that it has a long, happy stay in Worcester, cocking a snoop at those who would have it shot for causing a minor nuisance to their ridiculous hobby.

In fact, my hobby is keeping maggots and worms and occasionally bringing them to the river for a little swim. Can I shoot the fish that have the audacity to eat them please?

More Tea Vicar says...
3:26pm Fri 18 Jan 13

Presumably we need to kill all dogs, cats, foxes, predatory birds. And rabbits. Funny looking little buggers them.

Kill them all. Kill.Kill.Kill.

Sorry, just trying to get into the anglers' mindset. Doesn't work....sorry.

scolesy says...
3:19pm Sat 19 Jan 13

I spoke to some Canadian friends the other night,they said they wanted to go clubbing,,,,,,,,

Jabbadad says...
4:03pm Sat 19 Jan 13

With the deepest respect to the Poles who fought bravely alongside us in World War 2, I understand that the Polish Poachers over here are quite fond of Pike and other big predator fish, so don't shoot the Pike etc call the Polish Poachers, Win Win..

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree