Wheelie bins in Malvern get council go-ahead

MALVERN Hills district councillors will go ahead with the introduction of wheelie bins for recycled waste.

At a special meeting on Tuesday, members voted to approve a bid for £1.54 million from the Government’s weekly collection support scheme for the project.

Previous attempts to introduce wheelie bins have been highly unpopular, with opponents saying they are visually inappropriate, unsuitable for many homes in the district and not wanted by much of the public.

Council leader Councillor David Hughes told members that the council was obliged to introduce glass collection by 2015. This, combined with reductions in council grants from central government, jeopardises the current two-bag weekly collection.

Council officers recommend the best way to safeguard the weekly black bag collection was to introduce a fortnightly collection of recycled waste using wheelie bins. Coun Hughes said there was a “very real danger” that if the bid was not made, the council would end up losing its weekly black bag collection.

Councillors voted 21-8 with one abstention to approve the scheme, although few seemed enthusiastic.

Coun Anthony Warburton warned that far from safeguarding the weekly collection, the proposal would endanger it, saying that in a few years, the council would be pressured for “the abandonment of the black sack system and residual waste would then be collected using the already-installed wheeled bin system on a fortnightly basis”.

The meeting was controversial from the beginning, when council chairman Paul Tuthill left after being told that comments he made last week showed he had a “closed mind” on the issue.

Coun Tuthill had said wheelie bins were “totally inappropriate”, and John Williams, the council’s head of policy and governance, said that he should not take part in the meeting. He said that if Coun Tuthill took part, it could invalidate whatever decision the council made.

After several councillors spoke up in his support, Coun Tuthill decided to leave the meeting with Coun Clive Smith joining him in a gesture of solidarity.

Comments(5)

broadwas says...
7:39am Fri 17 Aug 12

Why impose wheelie bins on us at huge, unnecessary extra cost? I go to the bottle bank on the way to Worcester (no extra carbon footprint), and all my other rubbish, (nearly all packaging), is recycled in the pink bag. I have a waste disposer in the kitchen and a neighbour with hens, so food waste is not a problem. I have not put a black bag out for years!

Hwicce says...
8:53am Fri 17 Aug 12

broadwas wrote:
Why impose wheelie bins on us at huge, unnecessary extra cost? I go to the bottle bank on the way to Worcester (no extra carbon footprint), and all my other rubbish, (nearly all packaging), is recycled in the pink bag. I have a waste disposer in the kitchen and a neighbour with hens, so food waste is not a problem. I have not put a black bag out for years!
Because most people don't.

Apart from being a bit ugly and not very easy to store with terraced houses wheelie bins are much cleaner and way more efficient.

If Malvern had wanted to keep it's black bags then it should have recycled more. It didn't hence you're getting the wheelie bins. You only have yourselves to blame.

Guy66 says...
9:07am Fri 17 Aug 12

Hwicce wrote:
broadwas wrote:
Why impose wheelie bins on us at huge, unnecessary extra cost? I go to the bottle bank on the way to Worcester (no extra carbon footprint), and all my other rubbish, (nearly all packaging), is recycled in the pink bag. I have a waste disposer in the kitchen and a neighbour with hens, so food waste is not a problem. I have not put a black bag out for years!
Because most people don't.

Apart from being a bit ugly and not very easy to store with terraced houses wheelie bins are much cleaner and way more efficient.

If Malvern had wanted to keep it's black bags then it should have recycled more. It didn't hence you're getting the wheelie bins. You only have yourselves to blame.
Slap salp naughty Malvern! It's black plastic wheelie bins for you now......

Guy66 says...
9:08am Fri 17 Aug 12

Hwicce wrote:
broadwas wrote:
Why impose wheelie bins on us at huge, unnecessary extra cost? I go to the bottle bank on the way to Worcester (no extra carbon footprint), and all my other rubbish, (nearly all packaging), is recycled in the pink bag. I have a waste disposer in the kitchen and a neighbour with hens, so food waste is not a problem. I have not put a black bag out for years!
Because most people don't.

Apart from being a bit ugly and not very easy to store with terraced houses wheelie bins are much cleaner and way more efficient.

If Malvern had wanted to keep it's black bags then it should have recycled more. It didn't hence you're getting the wheelie bins. You only have yourselves to blame.
Slap slap naughty Malvern! It's black plastic wheelie bins for you now......

Jabbadad says...
6:08pm Fri 17 Aug 12

Having followed some of the debates over this issue, I have to agree with the statements from many saying that wheelie bins are not suitable for so many houses in Malvern that are built on and around hilly ground where the access is up and down steep steps. So who is going to haul these bins to the road side, NOT the Binmen I can assure you. they refuse in certain areas of Worcester for less hilly reasons than Malvern. So whether Coun Tuthill had made a statement or not could have meant that he was actually being more of a realist than others?

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree