Worcester council faces £300k budget black hole

SHORTFALL: A shopper paying for a city council-run car parking space by mobile phone. But not as many drivers as expected are using the facilities in Worcester. (52434501) Buy this photo » SHORTFALL: A shopper paying for a city council-run car parking space by mobile phone. But not as many drivers as expected are using the facilities in Worcester. (52434501)

A BLACK hole of up to £300,000 has been forecast in Worcester City Council’s finances, it has emerged.

The recession is battering the authority’s balance sheet, with car parking income £75,000 below budget for just April, May and June.

Now bosses say the 2012/13 financial year, which runs to next spring, is likely to end in a six-figure deficit unless “urgent” action is taken to ease the problem.

Based on the first three months of 2012/13, forecasts have been published saying income from charging for public toilets will be £5,000 below par. Trade waste fees, where the council charges private businesses for taking away rubbish, is forecast to be £100,000 below budget while building control income is also expected to be down £100,000.

Revenue from licensing fees for taxi drivers, pubs and clubs is also due to be down £25,000 at the end of the financial year.

A range of other revenue streams are being damaged, including money from disposing of certain categories of rubbish, cremation services and fees from renting floor space to exhibitors at Worcester City Art Gallery and Museum.

A report on the findings says: “The forecast at this early stage of the year is a budget deficit which could be as high as £300,000.”

It does say some areas of the council’s finances are showing surpluses, including staffing costs, and that there is provision in the budget of about £100,000 of spare money to offset some of the damage.

But that would still leave a likely deficit of £100,000-£200,000, and the report calls for “management action” to address it.

The black hole was criticised by Councillor Robert Rowden, a former leader of the authority, during a meeting at the Guildhall .

“It’s quite clear to me that even with the recent price reductions there are a number of car parks in Worcester which are cheaper than the city council’s,” he said.

“People will always go where it is cheaper, that is the problem.”

Councillor Paul Denham said: “It looks like all these deficits are down to the recession – especially areas like car parks, sports centres and so on.

“If that’s the case, what can we do? People are spending less and we need to restrict the damage.”

Councillor Pat Agar said: “These are very, very significant pressures, some of which are unnerving, I have to say.”

Lesley Meagher, finance services manager at the city council, told a meeting of the management performance and budget scrutiny committee it was “imperative” the gap is tackled.

“A management plan is being put in place to tackle the situation,” she said.

The council slashed car parking prices by up to 50 per cent for August and September in a bid to boost trade.

Comments(15)

Doesitmakesense?? says...
7:36pm Sat 8 Sep 12

Cripps - can they ever get their budgetary problems under control? Bust - boom every year - last year they had an underspend on salaries!! Then they gave £600K to Worcester Community Housing to smarten up the environment!! Why they aren't made to merge with another Council for the back office services to save money?? Perhaps too many vested interests and no-one wants to retire just yet!!

mayall8808 says...
8:31pm Sat 8 Sep 12

These councilors need to get a grip, there are so many empty shops due to mainly huge rate costs, yes i know the government set bisness rates but why haven't the council asked for dispensation to keep the city center flowing? 50p off the car parks, get a life it needs to be competitive with the others and with less disabled people being able to park near enough to get to the shops easy,( most i know go out of town now) well enough said that was changed in favor of more taxi ranks which apart from the cross area in the day time you hardly ever see one anywhere else.
As for a management plan where was it at the start of the year???that's what the services manager is paid for isn't it? Apart from that Redundancy has hit most famile's in some way so the city is going to struggle.

brooksider says...
11:05pm Sat 8 Sep 12

Mr Ditta will sort out this deficit.
With his creative accounting, the City's finances will soon be in the black.

CJH says...
11:10pm Sat 8 Sep 12

How many consultants did £300k pay for? Probably need some more now to find out what went wrong...

Endconreignforever says...
8:18am Sun 9 Sep 12

Perhaps they need to think of new ways of bringing in spending such as signing the film friendly charter with UK film industry, like Stoke, Gloucester, Nottingham etc. This would allow for easy access to filming and bring in much needed revenue. The dark Knight Rises was filmed in Nottingham and Worcestershire has some amzing scenery and buildings. Also Help new small businesses to start up with reduced rents and lower rates...Stop charging so much for parking and get some of those empty properties sold or rented...think of the long term not the short. Tourism is a huge income for worcester..the Christmas fayre and victorian markets success are essential and keep looking at reduced council taxs for low income earners and up taxes on those millionaires outside of the Wu city!

Jabbadad says...
9:58am Sun 9 Sep 12

Yes I agree that the council should look with some criticism at the monies allocated to particular areas and projects which have a definite political connection lurking in the background.
A good start would be the money awarded to councilors to spend on issues they saw fit. In most instances you could follow the thread of this back to their own political position, ie resurface a footpath in their own ward?
If you took away the vote catching money you would soon find the £300,000.

Ctrl Alt Del says...
4:36pm Sun 9 Sep 12

It has been stated many, many times on this site that if they keep putting up parking charges and rents etc then people will go elsewhere, but then what do we, the council tax payers know?

Hwicce says...
5:45pm Sun 9 Sep 12

Become a Unity Council by merging Worcester City with Worcestershire Council Council. A whole tier of Coucillors would be surplus to requirements and could be disposed of.

Just think how much money that would save.

Or is that to easy?...

take a deep breath says...
7:45pm Sun 9 Sep 12

We have been told that our schools produce students lacking in English and mathematical skills and therefore we should not be surprised when our local councillors and cabinet get their budgets forecasts wrong. You sow, you reap.

brooksider says...
9:11pm Sun 9 Sep 12

A bit off topic but doesn't this photo highlight the Council's problem with communication, too muddled.
A large sign isn't enough, there has to be a further 5 messages on the ticket machine and this is without the extra two for the August/September parking offer.

Jabbadad says...
9:13pm Sun 9 Sep 12

With a unity council you would still have the councilors from each party banding together as now, and also acting for their Wards.
So unless we have PR and compulsory voting, with the numbers of voters being evenly split between councilors we won't go forward at all. And can you see the political party's giving up anything. So we will go on as now where monopolies or Coalition are a waste of public money.

More Tea Vicar says...
9:15am Mon 10 Sep 12

The Council is clearly wasteful and poorly-run.

Car parking too expensive, and the parking spaces are often too small to park in. The ongoing taxi issues. A Park and Ride system with buses so slow you may as well walk. The ongoing mess and expense of the riverside footpath. The ridiculous senior management people, jobs and salaries.

Yet all the time we seem to find money for Trish Haines' salary, a diversity industry, the catastrophic South Worcs Wrecking Plan....

I know some things are City, some are County, but it's all part of the same picture. Local government here does seem to be incompetent and parasitical.

Sack a load of people at the top, focus on those services which are necessary, and do them well. Then we might see some progress.

More Tea Vicar says...
10:00am Mon 10 Sep 12

Hwicce wrote:
Become a Unity Council by merging Worcester City with Worcestershire Council Council. A whole tier of Coucillors would be surplus to requirements and could be disposed of. Just think how much money that would save. Or is that to easy?...
Sounds like a good idea.

I would welcome the idea of a Worcester City Council if it meant what it said on the tin.

But it doesn't. It is just a way of dividing 'responsibility' between different bodies, with no rhyme or reason.

That makes it perfect for doing what local government 'management' loves best - taking lots of money off us, but always saying that whatever you're complaining about is run by the 'other' body.

It just reinforces my view that the best place for many local govt. managers is anywhere but local govt. Let them 'man up', do jobs which count, and which are accountable. Who knows, some might even enjoy the experience!

I would sack virtually everyone at the top, and everyone involved with 'diversity', the SWDP, and 'marketing'. And on day 2....

MJI says...
4:08pm Wed 12 Sep 12

That is only the wages of two chief executives - no issue to worry about.

Vertis says...
11:49pm Thu 13 Sep 12

I love the worcester carparks, ive noticed there are more wardens than spaces. And they still seem to be recruiting for them every week!

I went to a carpark the other day, saw the prices and the amount of staff walking around and presumed it was valet parking and left it in the middle with keys in it, £30 fine later i realised that maybe worcester isnt posh enough to have such facilities yet and never will be with the amount they waste.

Was just glad that my car wasnt stolen with the keys left in, but luckily the 3 wardens talking in a circle were still there next to it when i returned 2 hours later, cant knock their security!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree