Second-hand furniture dealer blames charity shops for hard times

A businesswoman says the future of her second-hand furniture store is being threatened by an influx in charity shops.

Rosa Keenan, of Rosa’s Emporium, High Street, Evesham, blames the large increase in the number of charity shops for the closure of her second-hand furniture stores in Pershore and Tewkesbury.

She said that losing two shops in the last 18 months has led her to take on a new slogan, ‘charity begins at home’.

“I think the closures were because of the increasing number of charity shops,” she said.

“At least three opened up while I was in Pershore.

“The stuff was still coming in but people weren’t coming in, they go to the charity shops because it is the trend these days.

“We were getting swamped with them.

“Even Mary Portas said we are becoming a high street of charity shops.

“I am not taking anything away from the good work they do but now they are having a lot of furniture.

“They can get it cheaper than us traders, which we think is unfair. I have a new slogan, ‘charity begins at home’.”

Ms Keenan said she believes people should sell unwanted goods themselves and then donate the money to a charity which tells them where the money is going.

“I think people can be naive as to where the money goes,” said Ms Keenan.

“People should be donating to local charities not the national charities. It is not what it used to be, it is big business.

“Everyone is jumping on the bandwagon. It is great people want to donate to charity but I think they have crossed the line.”

Comments(6)

eves28 says...
11:34pm Fri 21 Sep 12

I'm not sure what her point is - she sells the same stuff as the charity shops, at twice the price. The only difference being she keeps her money and the charity shops donate to charity....

jb says...
11:49pm Fri 21 Sep 12

It sounds very much that she resents the competition after having the monopoly on second hand goods for so long. Also people don't go and buy things from charity shops because it's 'the trend' they go because either the goods are cheap and/or they like to think their money is going to a good cause.

CJH says...
12:22am Sat 22 Sep 12

Ooo - nasty case of sour grapes by Ms Keenan here I think.

Tony1952 says...
6:36am Sat 22 Sep 12

Life, especially in business, changes constantly, and we all must adapt to change.

If she cannot compete with the charity shops, then sadly it may be time to find some other line of work to do.

As long as the charity shops are only selling second hand goods, and not new, then I say that's life - cope with it.

imustbeoldiwearacap says...
8:22am Sat 22 Sep 12

Many charities now use commercial firms to collect and sell second-hand items - the collection firm then pays the charity an agreed proportion of the "profits". The charities who actually run high street shops are the only ones who sell donations directly!

New Kid on the Block says...
4:00pm Sat 22 Sep 12

Why do people expect charity shops to sell things cheaply?
They exist to make money to enable the charity to operate.
Surely if something is worth a certain amount in one shop it is worth the same in a Charity Shop.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree