Referees’ decisions costing us money says Warriors chief Little

CHARLIE LITTLE: Says poor refereeing decisions have cost Warriors at least six points this season. CHARLIE LITTLE: Says poor refereeing decisions have cost Warriors at least six points this season.

REFEREEING decisions could end up costing Worcester Warriors a six-figure sum this season, according to Sixways managing director Charlie Little.

Twice this term, Warriors have received apologies from referees chief Ed Morrison with regard to incorrect decisions that have gone against Richard Hill’s side.

Officials wrongly handed penalties to Bath and Gloucester on the last kick of the match which ended up costing Warriors six points, while JP Doyle’s award of a match-winning penalty try to Leicester last week was debatable to say the least.

The Aviva Premiership points that have gone begging because of these decisions is likely to result in Worcester missing out on the financial windfall that goes with playing in the top tier of European rugby.

Little said: “Refereeing decisions have cost us at least six points this season, which could be the difference between qualifying or not for the Heineken Cup, which is worth comfortably into six figures to the club.

“When Hilly said what he did after the Leicester game, I don’t think he was fully aware of exactly what had happened, especially the knock-on by Ben Youngs and how much the scrum had moved forward.

“There is often a little bit of a shove on, but not to be feeding the ball into the second row!”

Little added: “Over an 80-minute period you normally walk off the pitch happy to an extent that, although the referee might not have done a very good job, it has balanced out over the course of the match.

“However, if you make a decision in the 79th minute of the game that actually affects the result of the fixture, my view is that you have to be 100 per cent certain that decision is right. In our home game with Gloucester, JP Doyle made a decision he thought was correct, but was later proved not to be and the apology came.

“One would assume that he was again 100 per cent certain he had made the right decision at the end of our game with Leicester, yet clearly it should have been at least a reset scrum or even a free-kick or penalty to Worcester.

“If it was a reset scrum, Tigers may still have forced the penalty try, I don’t think we’re questioning that, but you just wonder why.”

Comments(6)

Worcester Lad says...
9:54am Sat 12 Jan 13

It's not always the ref that cost us points it's the Sin Bin men,unable to win away from Sixway's and team selection.All these things play a part,and it's been like this for a few seasons now.

Mr Philcoa says...
5:36pm Sat 12 Jan 13

Worcester Lad wrote:
It's not always the ref that cost us points it's the Sin Bin men,unable to win away from Sixway's and team selection.All these things play a part,and it's been like this for a few seasons now.
You are bringing up quite a separate issue and one that dilutes a very serious point being made by Charlie Little. When a match is played to completion and then the result is altered by a wrongful decision by the ref that is no small matter and in Worcester's case will surely have cost the club dearly financially and probably the fans too by denying them participation in the Heineken Cup.

By saying that the losses were our own fault is not only inaccurate as the team played well enough and scored enough points to win but it is also harmful to the Worcester MD's case that the refereeing is not at the level it should be. Your comment implies that the ref is fine and our loss was all our own fault.

RobertR says...
6:36pm Sat 12 Jan 13

Having watched the Warriors play for a few years now at Premiership level, whilst sometimes they've been masters of their own defeat . I do detect a certain referee bias towards the teams such as Leicester and Bath. Remembering the European Cup final match at Kingsholm. One had to conclude match fixing. In another game against Leicester Flood's penalty kick missed the post by at least 3 feet but was still given ?.
Now the recent incidents in last friday's match do raise questions towards bias. Charlie Little is right to question this. The RFU governing body are pretty hopeless.

deano220 says...
9:24pm Sat 12 Jan 13

I have to agree with both the above posts, but the comment on Worcester lads post stating that these are "separate issues" is a little harsh, surely the issue is not making the Heineken cup and to that end Worcester Lads comments are valid. The fact that last minute dubious or wrongful refereeing decisions cost us valuable points and possibly the rewards from Premiership placements is only part of our placing issue.
When you have a problem it is short sighted to focus on just one symptom, we should look at it as a global issue, yes we were the victim of poor refereeing, yes we have failed to win away for a full year, yes we have a serious habit of not closing already won games out and yes we need to stop having yellow cards. I am sure that Charlie Little and the rest of the management team are aware of these shortfalls and are working hard to rectify them but we must NOT be so focused on just one issue, every game mentioned was first won until the dying moments.

Guy66 says...
11:59am Sun 13 Jan 13

Why did the referee not use the TMO in the last minutes to validate the scrum. He was quite happy to refer the TMO on several other issues. Some of the decisions seem to board on bank account stuffing policies!

bigrat says...
1:10pm Mon 14 Jan 13

Against Tigers I think that JP Doyle gave Warriors more than their fair share of penalties throughout the match and overall during the season we have more than benefited from penalties being awarded to us and (on most occasions) the resulting 3 points from the excellent boot of Goode. So the point I am making is that overall I don’t think we can say that referees generally favour the opposition. Obviously last minute decisions get highlighted more than decisions made in the previous 79 minutes and yes it was unfortunate that JP or his linesman did not spot the obvious early push in that final scrum.

The question for me is bigger than whether Worcester should be 6 points better off, but the affect it is generally having on the game when week-in week-out the referees whistle is stifling open play and having such an influence on the result of matches. Maybe this is the reason why match attendances at Sixways are well down this season? Add another 2000 to every gate at about £30 per head and the numbers will more than make up for not being in the Heineken cup! Easier said than done I know but one thing is for sure, poor last minute decision or not, the match against the Tigers was the most exciting and talked about game this season!

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree