THE use of sheep and cattle in the management of the Malvern Hills has been criticised by a former conservator.

"Livestock and tourism don't mix," said David Masters. "I believe 15 to 20 sheep have been killed by dogs or so badly savaged that they have had to be destroyed."

He agreed that dog owners should keep their dogs under control, but thought it was too late to re-educate people after they had enjoyed the freedom of the hills without livestock for 20 or 30 years.

Mr Masters did not seek re-election to the board of Malvern Hills Conservators in October, but said support from the people of Guarlford had now persuaded him to stand at a by-election on Thursday, February 12.

He is strongly opposed to the management scheme involving the re-introduction of sheep and cattle to the hills.

"I feel angry about these living creatures being treated as a commodity and a tool. The sheep were introduced to clear scrub, but I have yet to see that," he said.

"Field staff spend countless hours clearing scrub and fence lines for electric fencing to contain the sheep, all at the expense of the precept payers."

Director Ian Rowat said the task of the Conservators was to manage the hills for the enjoyment of everyone, including dog walkers.

"We have more than one million people coming to the hills, which are the biggest attraction in the West Midlands," he said.

"Part of the attraction is the beautiful view and that is what we are trying to preserve. The cattle and sheep are doing a superb job in eating the birch seedlings and clearing the ground of scrub.

"The fact that we received an award from English Nature shows we are doing the right thing."

More than 50 dog owners attended a session on "sheep safe" dog training techniques at British Camp last weekend.

A cow that failed to thrive had been put down on the decision of stockmen when its condition deteriorated. It had nothing to do with dogs, said Mr Rowat.

Earlier this month the Evening News reported that four sheep were savaged and killed by dogs on the hills.