A DECISION on the controversial flood defence scheme for Upton-upon-Severn’s waterfront will be made next week.

The Environment Agency’s plans for a flood wall and landscaping scheme along the riverside will come before Malvern Hills District Council during a meeting in Upton’s Memorial Hall on Wednesday.

The plans will go to Malvern Hills district council without the backing of Upton Town Council, which this week voted against the scheme for the second time.

Although the agency had revised its plans to include a glass panel along more of the wall, councillors felt the designs would not protect the character of Upton’s historic waterfront.

Mayor Andrea Morgan said: “They have simply taken the top away from the wall, and the removal of the large viewing panels will prevent the beauty of Upton from being seen.”

Coun Sheena Walsh recognised the amount of work put in by the agency, but said the scheme was still not right for the town. “This is a permanent defence and will be there for a considerable length of time. If a wall is to be built then it should be something that is in keeping with Upton. I still don’t think we have reached a suitable compromise.” But Coun Peter Webb said: “Do you want a flood defence or do you want a derelict waterfront? We have reached a cross roads. Either we have a flood defence or act like Luddites.”

Only six councillors were able to vote on the plans, after the district council informed them that anyone affected by a connected application for a flood bund to protect New Street should declare an interest. Coun Tim Perry called the situation an “absolute farce” and said he would be discussing the matter with Malvern Hills council . I find it quite unfair that people who represent the town and have worked on this for a long time are not allowed to vote on it,” he said.

Councillors voted against the plans by four votes to two. Wednesday’s planning meeting is at 7pm and district council officers are recommending the plans be approved.